ENGL5010/Seminar in Composition &
Rhetoric/Thompson/Spring 2K8
Contact:
mthompson@csustan.edu, rhetster on AIM, 667-3591,
L195G at M 2:00-5:00, T 2:00-2:30 and by appt.
The
policies and syllabus will be updated as is needed due to changes in
assignments, due dates, etc. Please refer to the online version for the
most current information and check regularly for announcements posted to
BlackBoard.
Communication: Any course-related email must include "5010" in the
subject line. Please document most class business--especially any negotiated
agreements, problems, suggested changes in class, responses to my commentary on your
papers--in writing as e-mail.
Primary learning objective:
you
will emerge able to take more perspectives on and think more deeply about rhetoric.
Goals:
The course should enable
students to
- provide working definitions and
understand components of rhetoric and discourse (context,
audience, purpose, use, ethos, logos, pathos, etc.).
- understand a broad range of
Enlightenment, 19th century, and 20th century rhetorical theory
- understand the development of ethnic,
minority, and female discourses in relation to rhetorical theory
- write about interconnections of
a, b,
one's personal experience, and ongoing class readings and
discussions
- research, write about, and report on
one specific area related to the course of study
Approximate Class Format:
This list provides a general idea. Times
allotted may vary quite a bit in a given class session, and some
elements may not be included in some class sessions.
- 6:00-6:10: Questions, complaints, comments, and
requests--time for clarifications and possible changes .
- 6:10-6:40: Reports on Collaborative
Discussion Topic
- 6:40-7:15 Reports on Reader
Responses
- 7:15-7:30 Break
- 7:30-7:50:
Presentation on "outside" text.
- 7:50-8:20: Lecture/continued discussion of the week's topics and
readings.
- 8:20-8:30: In-class writing and reflection.
- 8:30-8:45: Read around and discussion of in-class writing.
- 8:45-9:00: Determination of Collaborative Discussion
Topic.
Traits of a Successful Student in this class:
- Must be able to attend class and conferences, arriving on time and prepared.
- Must do all the work assigned for the course on
time. This may seem simple, but it sometimes seems extraordinarily difficult to do.
- Must be self-directed enough to prepare for and execute earnest, thoughtful work during class time and outside of class.
- Must be willing and able to do research and photocopying of university-level texts outside of class.
- Must be willing and able to work collaboratively, including collaborative research and thoughtful responses to peers'
papers.
- Must be willing to make considerable revisions of papers.
Texts and Supplies: Required texts--The Rhetorical Tradition: Readings from
Classical Times to the Present, Second Edition; packet
of course materials..
Work Products:: There are 5 major and 1
minor work
products. The primary audience is always the class.
A. Reader
responses (RR) lead into the weekly class meeting and are a place to
allow thoughtful exploration which
interweaves issues connected to teaching, writing, your
experience as teacher/student, previous readings, classmates
responses to previous readings, and the readings under consideration
for the week. See the graphic:
http://rhet.csustan.edu/5001/RRgraphic.rtf These responses will
form the basis of your contribution to the ongoing class
discussions. As such, your RR must be posted to your group's
discussion board by 6 p.m. PT Sunday of each week beginning the second week of classes
(i.e., one day prior to class time). RRs
are not meant to summarize or comment on all the reading for
the week. Select what you think is an important point,
questions, issue, etc. RRs cannot be submitted after the beginning of class; RRs
submitted late but by class time will receive a reduced grade.
[Limits: 350-400 words ea.] Each class meeting one student from each
group will report the single most important point/issue from
his or her group's reader responses.
B. Collaborative discussion (CDT)
follows from the weekly class meeting and will require that you
engage in dialogue with others on a discussion board. Provide at
leas one substantive contribution to the discussion each week by 6
p.m. Sunday. (i.e, within six days after the end of class). The entire
discussion should flow from the initial posting--that is, don't
start a new thread for your response(s). Each class meeting one student from each group will report the single
most important point/issue from his or her group's discussion.
C. A research essay
(RE)
based on 12-15
journal articles or essays on a topic concerning rhetoric. Some of the mainstream composition journals are College Composition and Communication,
College English, JAC, Research in the Teaching of English, Rhetoric Review, Written
Communication. When you locate a useful article, be sure to use the works
cited page to locate other related articles and journals. Note that lack of
preparation for the conference may lower your grade for this essay. Your
research will be greatly facilitated by working with a reference
librarian. Speak to a reference librarian by calling 667-3233; set up a
F2F appointment by calling 664-6558.
The essay includes the four
sections described below; use the italicized words as headings in your paper.
You may include other sections as you see fit:
- Usefulness: details why one might
find the collection useful (brief)
- Perspectives:
talks about the range
of perspectives on and approaches to the issue at hand (general/fairly
brief)
- Discussion: discusses (analytically,
comparatively, and synthetically) the three or so most salient works
(specific/extensive). [Remember that analysis looks at the parts and how
they work together, comparison plays one component off against another, and
synthesis seeks to re-combine into something new (thesis antithesis-syn/thesis)
- Direction: recommends new directions
for research in the area (what new questions come to mind?) (brief)
The proportion of parts is important:
| Usefulness |
| Perspectives
|
| Discussion
|
| Direction |
Use MLA style for the
bibliographic and internal citations. A part of the grade for this
paper will come from your presentation of the RE during the final weeks of class.
See http://rhet.csustan.edu/5001/Presentation.htm
With approval prior to the conference this essay may
be done as a collaborative project by two students resulting in one
text. [Limits 6-8 pages
single-spaced as gauged with Times New Roman 12-point font excluding works cited
and visuals .]
D. Presentation on an
assigned text:
These will be articles or sections of the course text that you will read and present to the class. Your tasks are
to explain the important points of the text and to provide a one-page
handout which includes an aesthetically-pleasing, hand-drawn graphic (see
the APHG)
as a means to help us understand your presentation.
E. Presentation on CDT/RR:
Each week one person from each group will be assigned to report on
the most important element/focus of the the collaborative discussion
topic and the reader responses. Focus and specific
reference are important to this presentation are important See
http://rhet.csustan.edu/5001/CDTRRpres.htm
F. The midterm examination
is an in-class,
closed-text essay examination based on concepts covered to that point of the class.
Important notes about submitting and
re-submitting work: If your work
is submitted on time, you will have one week from the time I provide a
response to revise and resubmit. The time for resubmission of the
Research Essay may be more or less than one week--a final submission
date will be specified.
Grades:
| Task |
% |
| Reader responses (5
selected by instructor) |
25 |
| Collaborative
discussion (5 selected by instructor) |
15 |
| Research Essay
(level of preparation for conference and presentation on essay
affect evaluation) |
40 |
| Presentation on
assigned text |
5 |
| Reporting on CDT/RR (1
selected by instructor) |
5 |
| Midterm Examination |
10 |
Notes:
1. This class will employ the +/- grading system;
2. No quizzes, no extra credit work. 3. More than two absences will
warrant an 'F' for the course grade. 4.Incompletes (I’s) will be
assigned only when clearly warranted and when at least 80% of coursework
has been completed.
Disabilities: If a disability may prevent
full demonstration of your abilities, please contact me personally as soon as
possible so we can discuss accommodations necessary to ensure full participation
and facilitate your educational opportunity.
Plagiarism:
If you plagiarize, you will fail the
course. See the English Department policy on plagiarism http://www.csustan.edu/english/dept/plagiarism.html
. Review the samples of acceptable and unacceptable paraphrase at: http://rhet.csustan.edu/2000/plagiarismparaphrase.htm.
Complete the exercises at
http://www.dianahacker.com/writersref/ (click on Research Exercises then
on MLA*). If you have questions
about whether you are using a source fairly, ask me. The University also
severely penalizes plagiarists.
*You might find it useful to do all the exercises
in this MLA section of the Hacker site which include work on thesis statements,
recognizing common knowledge, integrating sources, in-text citation, identifying
elements of sources, and works cited pages.
Open University/Extended Education:
University policy dictates that
this course, if taken through Open University/Extended Education, might not count toward the M.A. in English.
Due
dates: [To top] The Reader Response deadline is the
Sunday evening before
class and the Collaborative Discussion deadline is the Sunday evening after class on
a 6 p.m. CST deadline.
|
Task |
due
no later than |
on |
| CDT1:
What is "rhetoric"? Response should then
be to the original posting or one of the other
responses; i.e., no new threads. |
6 p.m. |
Sun. 2/24 |
| RR1:
See RR listings on BlackBoard on your group discussion
board. Also see:
http://rhet.csustan.edu/5001/RRgraphic.rtf |
6 p.m. |
Sun. 2/24 |
| CDT2 : A
class member will make the initial post each week. |
6 p.m. |
Sun. 3/2 |
| RR2:
|
6 p.m. |
Sun. 3/2 |
| CDT3: |
6 p.m. |
Sun. 3/9 |
| RR3: |
6 p.m. |
Sun. 3/9 |
| CDT4: |
6 p.m. |
Sun. 3/16 |
| RR4: |
6 p.m. |
Sun. 3/16 |
| CDT5: |
6 p.m. |
Sun. 3/23 |
| RR5: |
6 p.m. |
Sun. 4/6 |
| CDT6: |
6 p.m. |
Sun. 4/13 |
| RR6:
|
6 p.m. |
Sun. 4/13 |
| CDT7: |
6 p.m. |
Sun. 4/20 |
| RR7: |
6 p.m. |
Sun. 4/20 |
| CDT8 |
6 p.m. |
Sun. 4/27 |
| RR8: |
6 p.m. |
Sun. 4/27 |
| CDT9 |
6 p.m. |
Sun. 5/4 |
| RR9:
|
6 p.m. |
Sun. 5/4 |
|
RR10: |
6
p.m. |
Sun. 5/11 |
| CDT10 |
6 p.m. |
Sun. 5/25 |
|
Research Essay (if to be discussed on 5/19) Send to
entire class, attached .doc or .rtf document (not .wps,
not .docx) and text pasted into body of the email.
Subject line should be: 5010: Research Essay |
6.pm. |
Fri. 5/16 |
| Questions for
Research Essays--respond to author via email. |
6 p.m. |
Sun. 5/18 |
|
Research Essay (if to be discussed on Wednesday
5/21) Send to entire class, attached .doc or .rtf
document (not .wps, not .docx) and text pasted into body
of the email. Subject line should be: 5010:
Research Essay |
6 p.m. |
Sun. 5/18 |
| Questions for
Research Essays--respond to author via email. |
6 p.m. |
Tue. 5/20 |
| Final revisions of
Research Essay. Send to instructor attached .doc or .rtf document (not .wps,
not .docx) and text pasted into body of the email.
Subject line should be: 5010: Research Essay.
Indicate revisions in bold type. |
6 p.m. |
Tue. 5/27 |
| See the
release
form. |
|
|
|
Syllabus: (Tentative.) [To top]
Week One (2/18): What
is rhetoric? & A few orienting highlights from
classical, medieval, and renaissance rhetoric
|
Reading: Gage,
"On 'Rhetoric' and 'Composition'"
|
|
Collaborative discussion topic (CDT1): What is
rhetoric?
|
Week Two (2/25): Enlightenment
rhetorical theory.
|
Readings for this week (RR1):
General Introduction 1-16; Introduction to Part Four
791-813; Locke 814-827
|
|
This week's
presenter on Vico 862-878: K Silva
|
Reporters for
this week: K. Costa, A Hollenhorst, B Lambert |
Week Three (3/3): Enlightenment
rhetorical theory.
|
Readings for this week (RR2): Hume
828-840.
|
|
This week's
presenters (2)
on Longinus 344-358: A Hollenhorst, E Silva
|
Reporters for this week: |
Week Four (3/10):
Enlightenment rhetorical theory
|
Readings for this week (RR3):
Campbell 898-946
|
|
This week's
presenter on Austin 890-897: T Hall
|
Reporters for this week: |
Week Five (3/17):
Nineteenth-century rhetorical theory
|
Readings for this week (RR4): Bain
and Hill 1141-1151, Spencer 1152-1167, Nietzsche
1168-1179
|
|
This week's presenters:
1 on
Grimke 1045-1060 Wyllie
1 on
Douglass 1061-1084 Bob
|
Reporters for this week: |
Week Six (4/7):
Modern and postmodern rhetorical
theory.
|
Readings for this week (RR5):
Introduction to Part Six 1184-1205, Bakhtin 1206-1245
|
|
This week's presenters
(2) on Woolf 1246-1269 Bahadur, Gonzalez
|
Reporters for this week: |
Week Seven (4/14):
Midterm
Examination (1 hr). Modern and postmodern rhetorical theory.
|
Readings for this
week (RR6): Richards 1270-1294, Burke
1295-1324
|
|
This week's
presenter on Weaver 1351-1360 Dyer
|
Reporters for
this week: |
Week Eight (4/21): Modern
and postmodern rhetorical theory.
|
Readings for this week (RR7):
Perelman 1372-1375, 1384-1409, Toulmin 1410-1433
|
|
This week's
presenter on Perelman and Olbrechts-Tyteca 1375-1383
Costa
|
Reporters for
this week: |
Week Nine (4/28):
MEET in
L195G. Research
Essay conferences: By this point in the term you will need to have a
clearly defined overall topic, have collected at least 5 articles on
that topic, and have some sense of the topics you will discuss in
your essay. Bring your articles, the plan for your essay, and
questions with you.
| 100 |
Katrina Silva |
| 130 |
|
| 200 |
Robert Souza |
| 230 |
James Dyer |
| 300 |
Faye Snowden |
| 330 |
Elyce Silva |
| 400 |
Susanne Herfurth |
| 430 |
Kris Costa |
| 500 |
Jose Bautista |
| 530 |
Bob Lamber &
Todd Hall |
| 600 |
Amble
Hollenhorst |
| 630 |
Sarika Bahadur |
| 700 |
Evelyn Gonzalez |
| 730 |
Summer Wyllie |
| 800 |
|
Week Ten (5/5): Modern
and postmodern rhetorical theory
|
Readings for this week (RR8):
Foucault The Order of Discourse
|
|
This week's
presenter on Anzaldua 1582-1604 Snowden
|
Reporters for this week: |
Week Eleven (5/12):
Ancient and postmodern rhetorical
theory
|
Readings for this week (RR9): Plato
138-168; Derrida Plato's Pharmacy (H/O)
|
|
This week's presenters
on
|
Reporters for
this week: |
Week Twelve (5/19): In-class
presentations of Research Essays. See http://rhet.csustan.edu/5001/Presentation.htm
|
Research Essay presenters:
|
Week Thirteen (5/21)
In-class
presentations of Research Essays. See http://rhet.csustan.edu/5001/Presentation.htm
|
Research Essay presenters:
|
Research
Essay
due Tuesday 5/27 electronically, attached to and pasted into email, by 6 p.m. Indicate
revisions in bold type.
See the
release
form.
|